WayToRussia.Net Guide to Russia
 
    Made by Travelers from Russia for Travelers Worldwide Guide to RussiaTravel ServicesOur Team
    >> WayToRussia.Net / Talk Lounge
  guide to russia
  what is russia
practicalities
transportation
russian visa
destinations
talk lounge
life in russia
 
  travel services
  apartment rent
accommodation
airline tickets
train tickets
visa support 
transfer / taxi
tours
extra services
 
  our team
Way to Russia Talk Lounge
Way to Russia warm-up: place both your hands in front of you and then count one word for each finger, starting from the left thumb: "Conversation Is a Way of Finding Out What You Think".
 
 FAQFAQ   SearchSearch   MemberlistMemberlist   UsergroupsUsergroups   RegisterRegister 
 ProfileProfile   Log in to check your private messagesLog in to check your private messages   ChatChat   Log inLog in 

WayToRussia.Net Blog & Updates:
 

Subscribe to Way to Russia News Feeds:
Add to My Yahoo! WayToRussia.Net Updates Feed Subscribe in NewsGator Online
Latest Forum Posts:
 

Talk Lounge Posts at Your Fingertips:
Add to My Yahoo!  Way to Russia Talk Lounge  Subscribe in NewsGator Online


Please, book your travel services directly through Way to Russia to support our free independent travel guide.

You will get lower prices, faster reply, and our backup in dealing with providers.



Could Kaliningrad leave the russian federation?
Goto page Previous  1, 2
 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Way to Russia Talk Lounge Forum Index -> Russian Contexts, Myths and Truths
Author Message
e
VIP


Joined: 23 Apr 2005
Posts: 654

PostPosted: Sun Apr 24, 2005 7:38 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
but we have a cottage in Abkhazia northwest of Sukhum, and I can speak for them.


Just because you have a dacha there, doesn't mean you speak for them. That's as absurd as Sean Connery saying he can speak for native Jamaicans just because he spends his winters there.

I may have overstepped the line when I said illegally occupying and to that, i'm sorry. Russian forces are only intervening as part of a UN sponsored peace-keeping force which was really requested, and came because no else recognizes Abkhazia (including Russia ironically), and that Abkhazia is so Russified. Again, if Georgia had the will or the means, or if the West cared, which they don't and if they do it would be for Georgia, Russia would've been long gone, just like everywhere else in the region.

Quote:
The Abkhazians and Southern Ossetians ASKED and REQUESTED our presense there to ensure their safety


This, my friend, is what I was saying last time. Your patriotism and pride is making you see the world through rose-colored glasses. Its no different than those Americans who say that Iraqis ASKED and REQUESTED American presence there. Oh! But wait! We buy all of our oil there, so Americans can speak for them right? Rolling Eyes

Cool
-E
Back to top
Vic
Talk Show Host


Joined: 29 Mar 2005
Posts: 298
Location: Moscow, Russian Federation

PostPosted: Mon Apr 25, 2005 11:56 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Actually, it does. I have alot of friends that are native Abkhazians and they say it loud and clear - Georgians will not come back here. And they are happy to have us there to protect them from Georgians, as they know that with us there the Georgians will not dare attack. I know that you think that everyone in the former soviet union hates Russia, but maybe you should look at the facts prior to making rushed dicisions?
Vic
Back to top
e
VIP


Joined: 23 Apr 2005
Posts: 654

PostPosted: Mon Apr 25, 2005 8:16 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I'm not just talking out of my ass either vic. I've got "facts" and experiences too:

I have friends and aquaintances from Ukraine, Lativa, Czech and Solvakia, Armenia and one South Ossetian who utterly despise Russians and resent the things that you guys have done to them in the past. The Latvian passed through Kaliningrad was she says the conditions are even worse than in Russia.

Then there is my ethnic Russian girlfriend from Kazakstan who says her and her family has experienced increased and intense discrimination from native Kazaks. The Kazaks she says are campanging to have Russian dropped as a state language and she says that Russians are leaving in droves because of the increased second-class treatment and discrimination. Her family who has been there from generations are considering moving back to Russia.

Besides personal experience, the facts speak for themselves: the fact that all of the Warsaw pact countries refused Russia's invite for VE day celebrations just to openly snub you guys. Not to mention the widely reported discrimination and second and third class treatment against Russians in the Baltics, Georgia, Poland and etc that my girlfirend experienced in Kazakstan and that my Czech friend says thats "what they deserve".
Back to top
Vic
Talk Show Host


Joined: 29 Mar 2005
Posts: 298
Location: Moscow, Russian Federation

PostPosted: Mon Apr 25, 2005 10:21 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yes, but we are talking about Abkhazia and Southern Ossetia here. I know that there are problems in the former Warsaw pact countries. But the fact is, they do not do themselves any good by treating us bad. Its like biting the hand that feeds you. Latvia for example, 25% of their national income came from a Russian oil pipeline and the Ventspils terminal. When they started acting up, we just shut that pipeline down and diverted the oil to the Primorsk and Mazhakai (Lithuania - they treat Russians pretty well, aunt lives there, I know). So now they screwed themselves, they loose free money and many jobs, plus, an empty pipeline still takes $$ to maintain, but does not give anything in return! Estonia also had some issues from 1992 to about 1998. But then they realised that it does them no good to piss off Russia, so as of 1999, Russian is MANDATORY in all schools and they don't build SS monuments anymore. Latvia is the only thick country left in the Baltics. I was in Tallinn 3 weeks ago and met with Russians living there, I was treated well and the Russians said that they are not treated like second class citizens anymore.
Kazakhstan, yes. I am from Omsk (border with Kazakhstan) and this does piss me off. There are more NATIVE Khazakh immigrants than I can count there not to mention just as many illegals. To top it all off you have flocks of Russians that had the unfortunate circumstance of ending up in Khazakhstan when the Union collapsed. You should have seen the German villages in Khazakhstan after 95'. The Germans were so pissed off at that treatment that they just left it all and moved anywhere they could, just out of Khazakhstan. For this, ofcourse they do pay. But the CIS countries in Asia are very primitive, not being racist, but it is true. After the Soviet Union collapsed, they regressed by about 50 years. Their attitude towards Russians isn't because they think that we treated them badly or whatever, they are just acting like gods on their newly aquired heap of trash. Can't say its all that bad either...look at how the real estate prices in Omsk tripled in the last 5 years just because of all the immigrants!
Vic
Back to top
MrSpice
Lounge Wizard


Joined: 14 Jul 2003
Posts: 3436

PostPosted: Mon Apr 25, 2005 10:53 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Long and boring discussion. One simple answer: Kaliningra will remain as part of Russia for the years to come. Period.
Back to top
e
VIP


Joined: 23 Apr 2005
Posts: 654

PostPosted: Mon Apr 25, 2005 11:59 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Monunments to the SS? I have never heard of this? How is this happening? I never thought that anti Russian hatred would spill over like that.

Well my friend, I agreed with you there. In fact my girlfriend's aunt had to move back to Karaganda (where the family is from) from Omsk because of anti-Russian discrimination. In fact, her best friend she grew up with in Kazakstan (who is German) moved to Germany because of the hatred.

And back to Abkhazia and Southern Ossetia. The South Ossetian I know said that she both welcomed and resented Russian influence. Welcomed because it kept the Georgians away and resented because she wants Abkhazia to be independent and that Russia is sticking their necks out because the Russians are only protecting their dachas and their resorts and not native abkhazians who were nearly exterminated by Stalin. What do you say to that?
Back to top
Vic
Talk Show Host


Joined: 29 Mar 2005
Posts: 298
Location: Moscow, Russian Federation

PostPosted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 12:48 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Finally we agree on something Very Happy
I'm glad that I have never had any anti-Russian descrimination against me in Omsk, although I can see how it can happen - there are entire neighbourhoods where they all move into. (Amur would be one of them, several years ago even the cops were afraid to go in! Now its safe but unpleasant.)

Well, I must admit that ofcourse, we are in Abkhazia for our own interests. No country ever does anything out of goodwill, there are always people's interests behind everything. Just one little thing to point out - you cannot just 'buy' cheap property in Akhazia, you have to be a resident to do that, otherwise all of Abkhazia would be bought out in two days. I can tell you how we got that datcha if you are interested, but its one of those 1 of 1000 chances, so it is very very very rare that a non-Abkhazian is going to own property there - its mostly tourists that either rent an apartment for a few weeks or tourists at the resorts.
The reasons that we back Abkhazia is political, as a matter of fact, tourism is far from being one of them. As you know, Abkhazia neighbours Krasnoyarsky Krai, which is the Russian "Florida" and they get very pissed off that in the last several years more and more people choose to go to Abkhazia (its 4 times cheaper for a resort which is of better quality). Coincidently, the only border-crossing into Abkhazia is from Krasnoyarsky Krai, so they do everything possible to make going to Abkhazia a living hell. The reason that we back them is political and only political. Most Abkhazians that I know, actually, I don't know any that aren't Russian citizens as of december 2003, want to be a part of Russia. It is in their interest, the quality of life is improving after being pretty low for almost 10 years. Their lives are more stable. Pensioneers get the (minimum Russian pension) of just over 1200 roubles instead of their Abkhazian 60roubles, not alot, but if you saw the prices there, you would understand. Not to mention the free medical care they get, and the fact that over 95% of the teens in Abkhazia go to study at Russian universities. There are many benefits. The other factor is that they do not have an economy that will be able to sustain itself without us. After all, you cannot run a country, albeit a small one from the proceeds of selling oranges.
Back to top
e
VIP


Joined: 23 Apr 2005
Posts: 654

PostPosted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 3:54 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Well since you put it that way, and you live there and all, I can't disagree with you there....... Smile

You shoulda mentioned this earlier instead of the patriotic outburst.

And I talked to the g/f about Omsk and she wasn't too surprised and that they're doing it in the Russian neighborhoods in Almaty and Karaganda.

Cheers mate!

Very Happy

-E
Back to top
mister_wizzz
VIP


Joined: 27 May 2004
Posts: 559

PostPosted: Tue Apr 26, 2005 11:09 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Vic wrote:
I was in Tallinn 3 weeks ago and met with Russians living there, I was treated well and the Russians said that they are not treated like second class citizens anymore.
Kazakhstan, yes. I am from Omsk (border with Kazakhstan) and this does piss me off. There are more NATIVE Khazakh immigrants than I can count there not to mention just as many illegals. To top it all off you have flocks of Russians that had the unfortunate circumstance of ending up in Khazakhstan when the Union collapsed. You should have seen the German villages in Khazakhstan after 95'. The Germans were so pissed off at that treatment that they just left it all and moved anywhere they could, just out of Khazakhstan. For this, ofcourse they do pay. But the CIS countries in Asia are very primitive, not being racist, but it is true. After the Soviet Union collapsed, they regressed by about 50 years. Their attitude towards Russians isn't because they think that we treated them badly or whatever, they are just acting like gods on their newly aquired heap of trash. Can't say its all that bad either...look at how the real estate prices in Omsk tripled in the last 5 years just because of all the immigrants!
Vic



The russian in Baltic countries are not treated like second class anymore, that's right, it was a condition of EU for integration.
About SS monuments, I ve never heard about that, it would have been very serious and brodcasted in every western newspapers, but it wasn't the case, I think it is simply a bulshit rumor you heard.
About Kazakh, I ve been there a lot of times, I met both KAzakh and russians, there is no hate beetween them, maybe there is discrimination in administration because national language (Kazakh) is now mandatory like in any former soviet republic. A Russian told me one day he consider being forced to learn Kazakh is humiliation. How russians could be integrated if they react so negatively ? It is the same in baltic republics, efforts should be done from both sides, russian pride in such situation is completetly unappropriate.
About Kazakh regression (50 years you told), let me tell you you are completely wrong, I saw myself the improvements in every fields : there is no more russians cars (only german, japanese, even french !), new buildings are growing eveywhere, new western types stores, restaurants , discos, common transport are now correct, roads are now much better etc ...
You have the colonizer syndrom, you think without russians Kazakh are bound to fail, I am sorry but according to what I saw, it seems they are not failing.
Back to top
e
VIP


Joined: 23 Apr 2005
Posts: 654

PostPosted: Wed Apr 27, 2005 6:27 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
The russian in Baltic countries are not treated like second class anymore, that's right, it was a condition of EU for integration


Uhmm...noo...They're still being treated like crap. And its not just Russians either, Roma (Gypsies) are still being treated like crap, and its not just just the Baltic countries but all over the new EU countries. Laws don't change peoples attitudes. Rolling Eyes

You're right and wrong about Kazahs and Russians. I pointed out to Vic how full of it Russians are when it comes to their pride, but my girlfriend's stories about Kazakh hate and discrimination sounded pretty harsh to be outright dissmissed.

There's anti-Russian backlash everywhere in these countries these days and there's no denying that.
Back to top
Zeus
Frequent Guest


Joined: 23 Mar 2005
Posts: 21

PostPosted: Thu Apr 28, 2005 1:01 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Kaliningrad stays Russian. Turkey should not join the EU. I'm sure the Turkish are nice people but they arn't Europeans. And for godsakes, Brussels, get Ukraine to join as soon as possible... losing Ukraine would be a serious loss and tragity for European security. Hell it might even persuade Russia to join the EU, which would accomplish what Napoleon and Hitler could not - a united Europe.
Back to top
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Way to Russia Talk Lounge Forum Index -> Russian Contexts, Myths and Truths All times are GMT + 3 Hours
Goto page Previous  1, 2
Page 2 of 2

 


Cheap Phonecalls to/from Russia

Way to Russia Phonecards







Get this Forum's Posts / Topic at Your Fingertips:
 
Add to My Yahoo! Add to Google Subscribe with Bloglines Subscribe in NewsGator Online Way to Russia Talk Lounge  Way to Russia Talk Lounge
(If you subscribe, you will be able to track new posts in this specific forum / topic. You can use your personal Yahoo or Google page, as well as specialized RSS readers.)
 
 


WayToRussia.Net - p-h-p-B-i-B-i